Archive for July, 2007

Orwell for a New Generation?

Posted by Paul Roberts on July 31st, 2007

Last week I posted this 1946 essay by George Orwell lamenting the degradation of the English language at the hands of political speech. Today I read “Reviving Anorexic Web Writing,” an article which applies similar thoughts to the web’s contribution to the degradation of the English language. The author is Amber Simmons, a writer and a web designer at the University of Texas at Austin, who writes elsewhere about many things including “theology and faith” — but from a perspective unsympathetic with biblical theology. What she has to say about web programming at intersection with society, however, appears to be rather helpful. She writes in her lament over the web’s contribution to the degradation of the English language:

As our culture becomes increasingly digital, the art forms that support it must be constructed with the same care, deliberateness, and gusto as our traditional media. Intelligent content is the literature of our time. It is not enough that our printed books and magazines are ardently written and meticulously edited. Our culture loses much if we encourage online writers to sacrifice grace and personality on the altars of pith and scannability. Perhaps better advice is to encourage writers to say exactly what they mean with precisely the words required, however many they may be.

This article was published in the online magazine A List Apart (ISSN: 1534-0295) which explores the design, development, and meaning of web content, with a special focus on web standards and best practices.

Popularity: 18% [?]

I Can’t Believe I’m a Librarian

Posted by Paul Roberts on July 26th, 2007

I never really aspired to librarianship as a child (who does?) probably because of perceptions such as these. Just for kicks I did a Google Books search on the phrase “librarians are like” and here are a few of the results. I actually found this somewhat discouraging — most of these statements were in library journals and indicate that we have something of an inferiority complex. If only the world understood us.

  • Most male librarians are like bulls in a china shop when it comes to the task of making a library look right. If local female talent isn’t available, … [Planning the College and University Library Building: A Book for Campus Planners and Architects - Page 93; by Ralph E. Ellsworth - 1960 - 102 pages;]
  • But I forget myself; we librarians are like Kentucky whiskey—some are better than others, but there are no bad ones! … [Library Essays: Papers Related to the Work of Public Libraries - Page 239; by Arthur Elmore Bostwick - 1920 - 432 pages;]
  • I believe librarians are like the unconquerable Chinese… [Illinois Libraries - Page 728; by Illinois State Library, Illinois Library Extension Commission, Illinois Library Association, Illinois State Library Library Extension Division - 1919;]
  • “Librarians are like pre-war Army quarter-masters, .. [Whigmaleeries - Page 4; by Scottish School of Librarianship - 1962;]
  • But first, we must get rid of some out-of-date ideas on what librarians are like: dry-as-dust, bluestockings, martinets, dragons even! … [The Assistant Librarian: Official Journal of the A.A.L. - Page 41; by Association of Assistant Librarians - 1997;]
  • children’s librarians are like the cigarette smokers in the TV commercial in this … [The Reading Teacher - Page 179; by International Reading Association - 1951;]
  • Librarians are like midwives. [Wisconsin Library Bulletin - Page 387; by Wisconsin. Free Library Commission, Wisconsin. Division for Library Services - 1984;]
  • Librarians are like artists: the good ones, given time, develop individual styles that are recognizable. [Making Sure We Are True to Our Founders: The Association of the Bar of the City of New York, 1970-95 - Page 332; by Jeffrey Brandon Morris - Law - 1997.]
  • A library is like a church, and we, the librarians are like priests and ministers… [RQ. - Page 28; by American Library Association Reference Services Division - 1960;]
  • Librarians are like scientists in this respect: it is never safe to ask them questions about anything outside of their show-case. [The Bookman - Page 506 - 1912;]
  • Reference librarians are like tourist guides in foreign countries. [This Business of Writing - Page 182; by Gregg Levoy - Language Arts & Disciplines - 1992 - 219 pages;]
  • Instructional librarians are like combat nurses, often ignored until needed, but deeply appreciated when they materialize at the right place at the right time. [Training College Students in Information Literacy, 2006-07 - Page 11; by Primary Research Group - Computers - 2006 - 73 pages;]
  • Librarians are like local politicians —they enhance their position by taking the best deal offered. [Publishers Weekly - Page 2608; by Publishers' Board of Trade (U.S.), Book Trade Association of Philadelphia, American Book Trade Union, Am. Book Trade Association, R.R. Bowker Company - 1873;]
  • Librarians are like people in one respect at least. [The Catholic Library World - Page 68; by Catholic Library Association - 1929;]
  • Librarians are like mothers. [The Educational Review - Page 235;]
  • Librarians are like fishers in the sea. [The Library Quarterly - Page 220; by University of Chicago Graduate Library School - 1931;]
  • We librarians are like the rest of the world. [Rice University Studies - Page 40; by Rice University - 1962;]
  • Dorothy Canfield Fisher has said that librarians are like missionaries in their
    zeal. We have to be. We are an integral part in the shaping of mankind and …
    [Bulletin of the American Library Association - Page 886; by American Library Association - 1938;]

I can’t believe I’m one of them. God must indeed have a sense of humor since I am now, and love being, one of them. Though I must endure the stereotypes, I do get to invest in theology students preparing for ministry by teaching them how to do substantive research. I guess I can endure being compared to a “dry-as-dust, bluestockings, martinet.”

Popularity: 16% [?]

Leave them Lightly Thumbed?

Posted by Paul Roberts on July 25th, 2007

A BBC News website poll which asks readers to identify ten classic English novels based on their first lines is more difficult than you might think. Their website explains:

Leading literary firms failed to recognise the work of Jane Austen when it was sent in by a prankster. The opening chapters of three novels were submitted under an invented name, with titles and character names changed. Think you can do better? Try our opening line quiz.

Take the BBC poll and try from yourself. I scored a 6 out of 10. Perhaps this previous poll was wrong.

Popularity: 21% [?]

alt="Feed" /> comments rss

Creative Commons Creative Commons

WordPress
eXTReMe Tracker